Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Alternative Dispute Resolution – ADR – is short form for anything that isn’t litigation or arbitration. Some may say that adjudication is a form of ADR – although as construction lawyers, we see it as anything-but ‘alternative’, particularly because it is mandatory in all construction contracts. There is, though, a significant place for ADR in construction.
Most of the time, when people refer to ADR in construction, they talk about mediation. Mediation is a consensual process (you can’t generally be forced to mediate) where an independent mediator tries to facilitate a settlement – often by banging heads together and asking the parties if they really want not to settle, and thereby spend a lot of money for the pleasure of spending the next few months or years sitting in rooms with lawyers. Given that choice, mediation often leads to settlement.
Mediation is very much in the mainstream – but other forms of ADR are available:
- Dispute Avoidance Panels (DAPs) can be useful on the right scheme. They are built-in to a contract and allow parties to refer issues to them during the life of a project. They are typically made up of construction professionals with a mix of experiences, who will try and find pragmatic solutions to avoid issues becoming full-blown disputes. Agreeing their terms of reference and powers is key, but they have been shown to work – notably being used with success on the London 2012 Olympic Games infrastructure works.
- Increasingly popular is Early Neutral Evaluation (ENE). The parties present their case to a neutral third party who considers submissions, and may even convene a meeting, before giving their view on who’s right and who’s wrong. It is perhaps not that dissimilar to adjudication – albeit that adjudication ends with an (at least temporarily) binding decision. Originally ENE was designed to be presided over by a judge (who wouldn’t then hear the case if it ended up in court), although now other senior lawyers or industry figures may be called on to participate.
- Expert determination sees an independent expert consider the parties’ submissions and evidence, and draw on their own knowledge and experience, to reach a decision. That decision will usually be binding (i.e. incapable of appeal, save for breaches of natural justice or jurisdictional issues), so a decision to refer to an expert determination can be a tough one. It is particularly popular in certain sectors where particular technical issues arise, such as in oil and gas works or power generation, and for that reason is built into some forms of standard contract including as published by FIDIC and IChemE.
Whatever form it takes, we know how ADR works and, just as importantly, how and when to deploy it. A mistimed invitation to use ADR or picking the wrong form can be just as damaging, if not more so, than not engaging in ADR at all – so it’s important that you know your advisors know what they’re doing. With us, you will.
Adjudication
Litigation
Arbitration
ADR (Alternative Dispute Resolution)
Development
Real Estate Finance
Contract Support
Solicitor support
Public Sector
I have worked with Hanna and the Archor team several times over the years on a range of issues. Hanna takes time to understand the commercial realities of a situation and has helped us navigate even the most complex of legal issues with her own style of prompt straightforward advice.
Dan Williamson
Director of Planned Works, Guildmore
I have been working with Ruth, Oli and the Team for a number of years. I find them to be knowledgeable and thorough as you’d expect, but also very commercially aware, responsive and easy to get along with. Working with them genuinely feels like they are part of our business because they care about the outcome.
Sean Robinson
Commercial Director
I have been working with Ruth and the Team for a number of years on various complex issues. They always go the extra mile to understand the commercial reality of situations providing detailed and well thought out guidance and legal advice every time. They are an invaluable support service when required and it is clear that they genuinely care about providing the best service possible to our business.
Daniel Maguire
Commercial Director – Rail & Infrastructure Division | VolkerFitzpatrick
Rory and the team at Archor provide HUB with an excellent service across our whole living portfolio. They are very responsive, knowledgeable, trusted and have built lasting relationships with the whole HUB team.
Damien Sharkey
Managing Director |. Hub Residential
I use Archor because it’s a one stop shop, I get made to feel important and like I’m a priority. They work quickly and allow me to get on with other things, and I trust their judgement and advice implicitly.
I don’t think I’ve ever had to chase you them on a legal matter, it’s normally the other way around which is another reason why I wouldn’t take our business elsewhere – I very much feel like we are a team working towards the same outcome.
Luke Harris
Construction Director | Frontier Estates
Oli and his team always seem to be able to grasp the situation you find yourself in. Even though we have a huge head start with regards the contract and issues we are facing, they are able to get up to speed quickly and then formulate a strategy that leads to a successful conclusion.
John Henry
Director | John Henry Group
It’s always a pleasure working with the team at Archor. They are proactive, diligent and happy to offer genuine, practical advice.
Alex Hall
Director | Common Projects
I find Rory to be very approachable, with a can-do attitude. Which combined with his attention to detail, understanding of the potential risks and practical approach makes him a very valued and respected member of our consultant team.
Spencer Burrell
Director | Big Sky Living
Adam was an excellent all around. Disputes can often be stressful so it is incredibly helpful to have someone who can cut through the fog to deliver clear and concise advice that was still meticulous. He was always quick to respond when needed and was great at balancing the legal position against the reality of a commercial environment.
Aslan Ryskali
Director | MBIL Developments
We work with Archor for our legal matters as we find their professional, down to earth, flexible, relationship lead approach adds additional value beyond the standard legal advice you would achieve with others. We have great long-term relationships at various levels and the results we have achieved with Archor’s help have been fantastic.
Mark Burrows
Regional Commercial Director | Breheny Civil Engineering
Dealing with the potential loss of our home and possibly much worse we found ourselves in a difficult and vulnerable position. Seeking justice as lay people is a minefield full of risk and uncertainty.
Fortunately we were supported by caring professionals at Archor, in particular Jessica Garrod, Associate. It was quite a journey, but Jessica and Andrew Rush (Senior Partner) steered us through the choppy waters.
We can never thank them enough and we thoroughly recommend them as solicitors, their knowledge and skill in relation to dealing with properties and institutions such as insurance companies is second to none.
Jane and Andrew Hibberd
Private Clients, Norfolk
